Dobby and Winky's Opposing Views on Freedom

PAGES: 379-381

Dobby expresses joy about his freedom and wages at Hogwarts, but Winky is horrified by the idea of being paid and remains loyal to her former master, Bartemius Crouch Sr.. Hermione, attempting to encourage Winky, only causes more distress. Dobby further explains house-elf enslavement and how Professor Dumbledore allows them freedom to express their opinions.